Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Unpacking the UN HDR for 90+ Post-Grad Students



Unpacking the UN HDR for 90+ Post-Grad Students

One of the privileges of today's technology is that it allows you to be in virtually two places at once... 

While I have called Dar es Salaam home for the past four months and counting, I've had many opportunities to share with family, friends and colleagues around the world stories, experiences and many lessons learned during my recent stay here in Tanzania.



On Thursday, September 26th I took it one step further. Being connected to past colleagues and professors at the Humber College Business School, particularly in the International Development Management Post-Graduate Program, I knew early after my arrival to Tanzania that I would like to carry on my annual tradition of being brought back to my "old stomping grounds" to speak about my work experience since graduating...this time from the global south and as a UNA Canada / UNDP Tanzania JPC.

While I had much "real-world" experience to share with the class of over 90 Post-Graduate students, I challenged myself to connect my work experience and exposure to the very curriculum that the students were learning in their International Development course. This happened to coincide with a discussion about Human Development Indicators and the Human Development Index (HDI). For those who don't know, the Human Development Index is the one value that economists Manbub uh Haq and Amartya Sen coined in 1990, used to rank countries in their levels of human development based on a composition of life expectancy at birth, education, health and income. While this formula later evolved to factor inequality margins into the equation, it has remained the focus of the annual United Nations Human Development Report, which has been published since 1990. 

The 2013 Report is titled "The Rise of the South: Human Progress in a Diverse World", therefore my presentation focused on the relationship between political participation and economic growth. The major finding that was discussed, is that in countries with lower HDI values, the gains that can be made from boosting political participation are significantly higher than in highly developed countries, where smaller gains in human development can be made. The purpose of this talk was to demonstrate that establishing an enabling environment for political participation is a necessary conduit to any significant economic gains that could be made in the global south. This is incentive for governments and development partners to invest in building stable and responsive political systems before attracting foreign investment into other sectors.

I would not have had such an intimate connection to this topic had I not had the opportunity to come to Tanzania and work with the UNDP, who's National Implementation Modality ensures that the Central Government directly takes ownership over every project we support. Capacity development of the National Government is key to ensuring participatory processes with local / regional governments and village councils are carried out to ensure accurate information, data collection and inclusive negotiation. UNA Canada has provided me with this excellent practical experience, which is more than a "window" into the world of the United Nations, but a seat at the table, and sometimes even in the driver-seat of critical, high-level projects that can impact the lives of Tanzanians for generations to come.

For this I am thankful.






Saturday, September 28, 2013

Photos from Tanzania's first National Elephant Day a.k.a. Siku Ya Tembo Kitaifa, 2013 

Every 15 minutes an African elephant is slaughtered. 

Poaching of the African Forest Elephant is a serious problem in Southern Tanzania as well as other districts where elephants are not under strict surveillance (i.e. national parks). The population of this mammal (arguably the biggest of the "Big 5" in both size and significance) has decreased by two thirds since the 1950s. At this rate, our grandchildren may read about elephants (along with the endangered rhinoceros which is also hunted for its horn) the way we learned about dinosaurs and the woolly mammoths at the museum. 

The main cause of elephant slaughter is the increasing demand for ivory goods (i.e. carvings and other luxury goods) in the emerging middle class markets of China and Thailand. Most practical items that were once carved from ivory have now been replaced by plastics and other synthetic materials (such as piano keys and billiard balls). Other reasons for elephant slaughter in some villages include for food, and protection of one's crops. However on September 22nd, the Government of Tanzania, Tanzania Wildlife Research Institute, University of Dar es Salaam and other partners convened the first ever "National Elephant Day" to raise awareness and discuss the serious impact that elephant poaching is having on Tanzania's biodiversity, ecological health, tourism industry and last but not least, the survival of the beloved species itself!

Enjoy some photos of this special ceremony that I was so privileged to take part in and relish in the significance of the "Great" African Elephant! We couldn't prevent the extinction of the animals that lived before man, but we have the power to preserve and live in harmony with the beauty and biodiversity of habitat to which our earth is now endowed. Perhaps the health and survival of our own race depends on it..
















Friday, August 16, 2013

Tales from the backseat of a Bajaji


Tales from the backseat of a Bajaji


August 16th, 2013.

July's blog was somewhat of a collage of the sights, sounds, tastes and experiences I encountered during my first month in Tanzania. Now that I have somewhat "settled" and somewhat developed a "who's who in the zoo" understanding of Dar es Salaam, I am modifying my blog format to try a 1-topic per blog approach...so that I can build on my stories, thoughts and feelings with time and experience surrounding various topics - rather than amass a series of chronological stories with no real rhyme or reason. This will also hopefully allow me to publish blogs faster, since I won't be reporting but rather reflecting on different topics at any given time. In the spirit of good governance I guess you can say I'm "decentralizing" my blog posts, allowing each one to have a life of its own rather than a finite lifespan...so without further adieu let us open a topic that most people in Dar es Salaam can relate to - whether local or expat - and we all have rode in at some point: The Bajaji


What is a Bajaji?

From my understanding a Bajaji or Bajaj as they are also called, is a three-wheeled, open-air (although some have vinyl zippered windows), and gasoline-powered cross between a car and a go-kart, similar to the rickshaws found in India or the Tuk-Tuks found in Thailand. They are found all over the streets, sidewalks and dirt roads of Dar es Salaam, and can reach the speed of traffic in most cases here. A friend of mine here in Dar tells me they were initially meant to help people on the outskirts of town get past the narrow roads and into the main areas where they could then take a Dala Dala (local bus) or taxi. However given their convenience of speed and comfort, they have taken advantage of their lower cost of fuel to offer a middle-road price to both foreigners and locals who do not like to sit in traffic in an expensive taxi or the cheapest of them all, but equally as slow and almost always crammed with people, Dala Dalas. Today I took my first dala-dala ride just to say I've done it but for a guy my height standing in a dala dala hunched over the people lucky enough to get seats -- not something I could get used to doing, especially to and from work in business attire.

Limon - my first 'regular' bajaji driver to work and back each day.

How did I come to appreciate bajajis?

When I first arrived in Dar last June, I had no intention of buying a car nor taking a taxi to and from work each day, given the cost in both time and money associated with traffic in the city center.  However, given the distance from my temporary residence, the office was not walk-able distance, so my Tanzanian friend who helped me settle negotiated a decent rate with a local bajaji driver to take me to and from work each day = 5,000 Tanzanian shillings each way. I later came to know this was the standard price for any bajaji that had to cross the dreaded Selander Bridge into or out of town, because this is the bridge that foreigners are advised not to cross on foot, for many have reported thieves jumping out of the bushes that border this bridge. For me that was enough info to know I would never attempt crossing this bridge on foot, but I have gotten close and once paid a bajaji 3,000 to literally take me from one side of the bridge to the other, so I could continue my walk home. Anyways that's another story...knowing myself I will probably not let myself leave Tanzania without crossing this bridge at least once by foot - in broad daylight of course. But maybe I'll let that one percolate a bit more ;)

The benefits of taking the bajaji:

So aside from the greater chance of being on time for work and getting home at a reasonable hour by driving on the sidewalk and slipping in-between cars almost as seamlessly as a motorbike (another thing I've never tried but is not high on my bucket-list). The 30 minute bajaji ride to and from work has been my time to plan, reflect, organize my to-do reminders in my mobile calendar; but most important of all this has been a great way to improve my Kiswahili!

It's not so much the bargaining for price, since once you find your regular driver and agree on a price the bargaining is done...but it's the small talk with the driver while he drives (I've yet to encounter a female bajaji driver here):
"Asubuhi kaka, habari gani?" = "Good morning my brother, how are things?"
"Leo, nitataka mkutano, saa moja na nussu" = "Today, I have a meeting at half past seven"
"Habari za kazi?" = "How's work?" 
"Saa mchana, nitakwenda nyumbani kwa mimi rafiki" = "This afternoon, I'm going with a friend"
"Kila siku, ninapiga elfu sita shingapi" = "Everyday, I pay 6,000 shillings"

That is the extent of my bargaining strategy, to reassure the driver that he will have steady income if he picks me up each day, rather than nickel and dime for the best price. Which brings me to the next section:

Bargaining with Bajaji

To me, one of the allures of travelling is to experience the marketplace. To a certain extent, everything is negotiable, and I always return to Canada wondering how North American or European businesses got so good at convincing us to accept that since the price is printed in a menu, on a price-tag or lit up screen, we need to accept that price. Nothing could be more evident than if you've ever gone to a movie theater and paid more than $10 for one bag of popcorn and two sodas. 

But then we as tourists come to Tanzania, Thailand, Dominican Republic or other destinations and are surrounded by vendors. Street vendors selling cashews, coat hangers, magazines, cell phone chargers (sometimes even cell phones without the package). They approached us so we have the bargaining power. However in the instance of bajaji, you could keep a series of drivers in your phone book to call upon when you need them, or you can walk down the street and wave, whistle, yell or something to flag one down. Empty bajajis will often honk at foreigners as they approach you to signal that they are available if you need a ride. Once you are able to curb one of them, the negotiation begins...


"Rafiki, ninakwenda sokosamaki msasani, unajua?" = "My friend, I'm going to the Msasani fish market, do you know where that is?" (drivers will seldom reply "no", to get your business, then if lost they will pull over and ask another for directions)

"Ndio? Shingapi?" = "Yes? How many shillings then?"

The conversation can go back and forth until you agree on a price or the driver leaves you to continue walking. Typically, I have a general sense of how far I'm travelling and what it usually costs to go that distance...the driver usually starts with a high price, so you don't want to get in and then be forced to pay whatever he tells you. But there are times (like today), that I had to make an important deadline and rather than negotiate, I told the driver that if he got me there on time, I would pay the price he asked. I realize this could have been somewhat of an unsafe request, but I just wanted to make sure that if stuck in a traffic jam he wouldn't just sit there, because sometimes that's what they do even if they have room to drive between cars, so now I was giving him some more incentive to take the most efficient route he knew. I could always say "pole-pole" if I wanted him to slow down ;)

I often think about the consequences of bargaining with the bajaji drivers for lower prices. I have asked my regular drivers how much they are left with at the end of the day after subtracting fuel and maintenance costs (also, some of them don't own their bajaji and have to pay a rental fee). I don't think I could survive on the equivalent of $10-20 a day in Dar, let alone support a family. But many of them do and this is still significantly higher than the average income in Tanzania. Also, they can use their vehicles for other purposes, so they are quite a good asset for a young family (unfortunately they still pollute the environment - I'm wondering why they don't make these run on rechargeable batteries?)

In any case even if you take the first price quoted for a bajaji or taxi here in Dar es Salaam, it's still half as much as what the equivalent trip would cost in the developed world. The taxi's here don't have meters and if they did I would doubt they'd start with $3.50 on the meter just for getting in the car. Still I know many expats working in Dar es Salaam who use the bajaji and try to get the lowest possible price, even to the point of yelling or walking away from the bajaji only to find he will accept the price you want to pay and drive behind you to pick you up and take you where you want to go. I just don't have the spine to be that kind of a hard bargainer when it comes to short drives. The Tanzanian shilling doesn't get smaller than 50, which is approximately equal to 8 cents. Typically prices for rides are quoted by the thousand shillings, and you could get a bajaji to take you about one kilometer for 1,000 shillings. This is borderline hitch-hiking. Except with any livelihood activity their needs to be a markup in order to give the worker some incentive to conduct the income-generating activity as opposed to just everyone being a farmer or fishermen to feed themselves. I try to remind people that when a bajaji is asking you for an extra 500 shillings instead of the price you want to pay, that is less than 50 cents. Is it really worth all the back and forth? You are entrusting your safety to a driver of a vehicle that does not contain seatbelts...maybe it's better to start off on the right foot than get into the cart with a disappointed driver. Your decisions could be the difference between a starch-filled diet and a healthy one for his family. And if you are really on such a tight budget - there's always the dala-dala ;) 







Sunday, July 14, 2013

Settling In - Stories from my first month in Tanzania

Settling into Dar es Salaam & UNDP Tanzania


Today marks exactly 1-month that I boarded American Airlines in Toronto, and traveled via Washington DC and Ethiopian Airlines to my long anticipated field placement in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Being my first time visiting the African continent, my eyes were glued to the airplane window most of the flight...




Upon arrival to Nyerere airport I was relieved to encounter no delays in retrieving my suitcase, and a very friendly colleague from UNDP kindly met with me at the airport, helped me get some local currency and get settled at my temporary hostel.

Consolata Fathers - Private Missionary Residence

Not only was I picked up at the airport, but I was staying at a very inviting guesthouse where the landlord spoke English and Italian, in addition to Kiswahili. Needless to say I felt very welcome - and this made a world of a difference as I navigated my new surroundings, sharpened my language skills and figured out a very important thing - the Tanzanian telecommunications options...introducing Vodacom:

Vodacom and I would develop a love-hate type of relationship over the coming weeks. Cell phones here are marvelously advanced, while internet is kind of like electricity - not everyone can have it at the same time!

(I can just hear the missionaries and development workers from the 80s and 90s now, telling us how we've got it so easy with all our fancy modes of communicating with back home!)

I thought about sending a postcard today...I really did ;)

My first weekend in Dar was awesome and it was a slight sensory overload with all the sights and sounds of my new environment. The howling dogs outside at night, the car-honking, the crowds, the street vendors...I welcomed every minute of it. I was also very blessed to have a nice mix of Canadian, expat and Tanzanian friends to spend my first weekend with. Right from the get-go I've made a point of keeping my leisure time balanced between the local scene and the expat scene, and there is certainly considerable differences between the two. 

Slipway Shopping Centre on the Masaki peninsula


The 'Loblaws' of Dar es Salaam
 


Official taxis will have a green stripe on the side of the car. Other 'taxis' will also offer you rides.

Mishkaki - skewered meat & roasted bananas

Nyama choma kwa ugali - barbecue meat and accompanying sticky porridge, to be dipped in hot sauce, chilies, etc.
 No complaints about the food here so far!


Three days after my arrival I started my placement with UNDP. It was great to be greeted in the lobby by my supervisor and given a tour of the office while being introduced to everyone individually. Then came some admin. stuff - my laptop, desk, request for IT access and scheduling of my security briefing the following day. I was introduced to the Economic Growth Programme Specialist whom I would be working closely with, and I rounded out the day with some briefing on UN Project policies and procedures...lets not forget taking my Access Badge photo:

My second day on the job my colleagues started a running joke saying "yesterday you were new, but today you're not new", basically saying "now we can be tough on you and give you lots of projects" - I felt right at home :)

Local Restaurants

My first week at UNDP some of my colleagues kindly took me under their wing and showed me where they normally go for lunch. These places were lovely (i.e. the National Museum, the Tourism College of Tanzania, etc.), and somewhat inexpensive in comparison to Canadian restaurants...however I knew that the local places on the street were serving the same food for much less, and I really wanted to try them out and support them. Everyday I would pass these places, see the barbecue and wish I could just eat there...so finally I decided to ask some of my Tanzanian colleagues in the office if they ever eat lunch there - sure enough they did and I asked if I could join them. After a couple of these "stints" and getting to know the cooks and waitresses I now am just as comfortable with going there myself everyday. The local place is famously referred to as "Holiday Out" restaurant since it is located across the street from the Holiday Inn hotel. Genius!

"Holiday Out" Restaurant
Gravity-fed handwashing

Celebrating Canada Day on July 6th at the High Commissioner of Canada in Tanzania's Residence


Mr. Alexandre Lévêque - High Commissioner of Canada to Tanzania
 



Barack Obama "fever" sweeps over Tanzania!

People at work were joking with me saying my time of arrival couldn't be better! In my second week in this beautiful country, I was not only invited to the Canadian High Commissioner's barbecue for Canada Day, but I also got to witness all the preparation and anticipation for the two days US President Barack Obama would spend in Dar es Salaam, concluding his Africa Tour. It was a privilege to share in the local excitement, and hear how highly revered Mr. Obama is over here among Tanzanians. If you look at the map of Dar es Salaam on Google Maps, you will see that they have already changed the name of part of Ocean Road to "Barack Obama Drive"...before I saw this I thought all the talk was just rumors, but one thing I've learned about Tanzania is people here never say things just to amuse themselves - they mean it! I wonder if they'll ever take the signs down?